Gå til innholdet

The Black Layer · 3 for 2 frem til

Nyheter

How to Stop Your Dress Shirt Puffing Out at the Back

By The UNDR Team · November 9, 20268 min lesetid

A dress shirt puffs out at the back because there is more fabric than your torso needs, and that spare fabric collects above the waistband. The quick fixes are a military tuck, a belt and trousers that sit higher. The lasting fix is a shirt that fits, either a narrower cut or a tailor who takes it in.

A close-fitting layer underneath can help the tuck hold. It cannot remove fabric that shouldn't be there.

På denne siden
  1. Why dress shirts billow at the back and sides
  2. The military tuck, step by step
  3. Shirt stays and garters
  4. Tailoring: often the real fix
  5. Slim fit or regular fit?
  6. Higher-rise trousers and a belt
  7. How a fitted layer underneath helps
  8. A quick plan, in order
  9. Quick answers
  10. Where UNDR fits

Why dress shirts billow at the back and sides

Most shirts billow for one of four reasons: the cut is too full, the size is wrong, the shirt is too long or too short, or the tuck has worked loose. Finding the main one tells you which fix to try first.

  • The cut. Ready-to-wear shirts are cut to fit many bodies. A shirt that fits your chest and shoulders can still carry spare width at the waist and lower back. StudioSuits, a custom clothing maker, notes in its guide to billowing that tall, slim men often have the most trouble with it.
  • The size. A size up for comfort means extra width everywhere, and it collects at the back.
  • The length. Suitsupply's fit guide puts it plainly: a shirt that is too short will "come untucked easily", while one that is too long creates excess fabric that bunches in the trousers. A dress shirt should be long enough to almost cover the seat.
  • The tuck. Every time you sit, lean forward or reach, the shirt is pulled up a little. Without a belt or a firm tuck, it drifts over the waistband.

A simple test helps. Stand straight, tuck the shirt, then pinch the fabric at each side of your waist. If you can pinch several centimetres on each side, the problem is mostly fit. If the shirt is close but still creeps up by lunch, the problem is mostly the tuck.

The military tuck, step by step

The military tuck folds the spare fabric at your sides into flat pleats behind you, so it can't gather at the back. It costs nothing and is the first thing to try.

StudioSuits describes it in five steps. In our words:

  1. Put the shirt on and button it. Open your trousers and let the shirt hang straight at your sides.
  2. Pinch the spare fabric at one side seam between finger and thumb, a little below the armpit down to the hip.
  3. Fold that fabric back towards your spine, so it lies flat in a vertical pleat.
  4. Hold it, and repeat on the other side.
  5. Pull your trousers up over the folds, button them and close your belt.

Always fold towards the back, never towards the front, or the fold shows below your front buttons. Task & Purpose, a US military news site, described the same method in 2014 as tucking the excess fabric "in around your back, on either side."

The limit: a military tuck folds spare fabric away, it doesn't remove it. On a very full shirt, the folds get thick and show as ridges under a fine cotton. Brock McGoff of The Modest Man also skips it on very slim shirts, in his guide on how to keep your shirt tucked in.

Shirt stays and garters

Shirt stays are elastic straps that run from the hem of your shirt down to your socks or a band around the thigh or calf. They pull the shirt down gently all day, so it can't ride up. They work well, and they take a few days to get used to.

McGoff calls them "the best accessories for keeping your shirt neatly tucked in all day long." He adds a practical number: his stays need at least 13 inches between the top of the sock and the bottom of the shirt, or there isn't enough tension for them to work.

Primer Magazine tested a pair for a wedding. Its writer explained why they work: "if there's no loose shirt below your belt or waistband, untucking simply isn't possible." He also found them confusing to attach at first. The review was sponsored, so weigh it accordingly.

Two honest downsides. You have to unclip them in the bathroom. And they hold the shirt down without changing its width, so a very full shirt can still balloon.

Tailoring: often the real fix

If you can pinch a lot of spare fabric at your sides, a tailor is the fix that actually solves the problem. Taking in the side seams or adding back darts removes the width that causes the puffing. It is usually affordable and lasts for the life of the shirt.

Two common options:

  • Taking in the side seams. This is the standard alteration. It narrows the shirt from the underarm to the hem.
  • Adding darts. These are two vertical folds stitched into the back. They shape the waist and the lower back more sharply.

Derek Guy of Put This On explains the choice in a 2016 column on darts vs side seams: taking in a billowy shirt is almost always worth it, and the only question is how much. He suggests side seams for modest taking in and darts for bigger differences or dressier shirts. He also warns that darts can leave small holes if you remove them later, so test them on one shirt first.

Roughly what it costs. Prices vary a lot by city and tailor. As a guide:

Source Alteration Price quoted
The Modest Man (US) Taking in the shirt body $20 to $40
The Modest Man (US) Darts, if charged extra $15 to $25
Put This On (US, 2016) Adding darts about $20
Acorn Fabrics (UK) Altering a dress shirt in general at least £25 to £50
BonneGueule (France, 2012) Taking in a shirt (cintrage) about €25 average

Take these as ballpark figures, not quotes. If the shirt cost less than the alteration, a better-fitting new one may be the smarter buy.

Slim fit or regular fit?

Choose the cut that matches the gap between your chest and your waist. If your waist is much narrower than your chest, a slim or tailored fit removes most of the spare fabric before you ever tuck. If your chest and waist are close in size, a regular fit may sit better, and a slim fit may pull at the buttons.

Try each in front of a mirror, seated and standing. A slim fit that pulls into X-shaped creases across the front is too tight, and it will untuck every time you sit. A regular fit that folds into a skirt of fabric above your belt is too loose.

Higher-rise trousers and a belt

Where your trousers sit changes how much shirt shows above them. Trousers that sit at your natural waist hold the shirt higher and tighter. Low-rise trousers leave a longer stretch of shirt between chest and waistband, and that is where the puffing collects.

A belt matters too. StudioSuits lists it among its main fixes: a firm waistband holds the tuck, and trousers that sit loose on the hip let any shirt drift.

StudioSuits also suggests sitting back in your chair. Leaning forward pulls the shirt up with every move.

How a fitted layer underneath helps

A close-fitting layer under the shirt helps in two ways. It gives the shirt a smooth base with no loose undershirt fabric to fold and gather, and if it is anchored below the waistband, it doesn't ride up.

The honest scope: a compression layer will not take spare width out of a shirt that is too big. That shirt still needs tailoring. What the layer changes is the base under the shirt and how well the tuck holds.

  • A loose cotton undershirt can make it worse. It can grip the shirt and drift up with it. McGoff's workaround is the "undertuck": tuck the undershirt into your underwear, then the shirt into your trousers.
  • A close layer removes that problem. It sits flat to the skin, so there are no folds of undershirt adding bulk at the waist.
  • A bodysuit goes one step further. It is anchored below the waistband, so it stays put when you sit or reach. The shirt over it keeps a smooth base all day.

Black Lapel, a custom suit maker, advises against compression shirts worn as a shaping trick. Its view, in its undershirt guide, is that overly tight garments are "no substitute for well-fitted clothing." We agree with the core of that. Fit the shirt first. Then choose a layer in your true size, not a size down for extra hold. If anything feels too tight or affects your breathing, take it off, and talk to your doctor if you have a health concern.

For more on the line under a shirt, read our post on a cleaner line under a dress shirt. If you prefer a half-tucked look, see why French tucks look better over compression.

A quick plan, in order

  • Today, for free: military tuck, belt on, trousers at your natural waist.
  • If it still creeps up by lunch: shirt stays, or a fitted layer that stays put.
  • If you can pinch a lot of fabric at the sides: a tailor, to take in the sides or add darts.
  • Next time you buy: a slim or tailored fit if your waist is much narrower than your chest, and a shirt long enough to cover the seat.

Quick answers

Why does my dress shirt puff out at the back?

Usually because the shirt has more fabric at the waist than your body needs, so it gathers above the waistband. A loose tuck, low-rise trousers or no belt make it worse.

How do you stop a dress shirt from puffing?

Start with a military tuck and a belt. If it still billows, have a tailor take in the sides or add darts. A narrower cut also helps.

Does the military tuck really work?

Yes, for a moderate amount of spare fabric. It folds the excess flat behind you. On a very full shirt the folds get thick, and tailoring works better.

How much does it cost to take in a dress shirt?

Often about $20 to $40 in the US, or around €25 in France, according to menswear guides. Prices vary by tailor, so ask for a quote first.

Can a compression layer stop a shirt from puffing?

Partly. It gives the shirt a smooth base and helps the tuck hold all day. It does not remove spare fabric, so a shirt that is too full still needs tailoring.

Where UNDR fits

UNDR makes the layer for the last part of the fix: a shirt that already fits, worn over a base that stays put. Two pieces suit this job.

  • The Full Compression Body (€68,99) is a bodysuit that runs from shoulder to hip, with an open-crotch base. Anchored below the waistband, it stays put, which helps the shirt over it stay tucked. It is a high-stretch blend of 88% nylon and 12% spandex in black or white. Read more in the Full Compression Body explained.
  • The Core Support Compression Vest Tank Top (€43,99) is sleeveless, so no sleeve line shows under your shirt. It is an 80% nylon blend with flat bonded hems, in black (S to 3XL) or white (S to 2XL).

Not sure of your size? Our sizing guide explains how to measure. Still deciding whether to wear anything under your shirt at all? Start with should you wear an undershirt under a dress shirt.

UNDR everything.

UNDR everything.Everywhere.Det innerste lagetFri frakt i EUDiskret emballasjeUNDR everything.Every journey.UNDR everything.Everywhere.Det innerste lagetFri frakt i EUDiskret emballasjeUNDR everything.Every journey.

Handlekurven din

Ingenting i handlekurven ennå.

Se alle plaggene

The Black Layer

3 for 2 på alle plagg: ta tre valgfrie, så spanderer vi det rimeligste.